Here are a few thrifty Henleys to choose from!
Option for the fashion adventurous Guy:

If you have no problem sporting purple this Converse One Star brand Henley is only $4.98 at Target!
For the "play it safe" Guy:

This blue (also available in green) Henley is also by the Target One Star brand for $13.98!
For the "Check out these Arms" Guy:
Also at Target as part of the Mossimo brand for only $9.99!
Also available in Ebony, Military Blue, River Birch, Bright Olive, and Teal Blush.
For Mr. Blue Eyes:
This Raglan Knit Top for 15.90 at Forever21.com will make your eyes pop!
For the Brown-Eyed Cutie:
By French Connection at Sears' Men's SS Solid Henley $14.90!
For the Buff Guy:
Wear this Route 66 Men's Long Sleeve Solid Thermal Henley at Sears' tight! It's only $6.99!
For the thinner Guy:
Try a baseball style Henley like the On The Byas Raglan Smith Henley for $19.99 at PacSun.
Enjoy!
Hurley Trixie Ruffle YC Dress $15.60
Roxy Wave Watch Dress $13.80
Rip Curl Tory Dress $21.60

Pleat Front Dress Forever21 $36.00
Satin Bubble Dress Forever21 $14.50
Berries N Cream Contrast Dress Forever21 $29.80
One Shoulder Knit Dress Forever21 $22.80
Ava Black Diagonal Button on the Bias Sears $21.00
Romeo and Juliet Couture Knit Sweater Sears $15.00
Heritage 1981 Women Collegiate Cardigan Forever21 $ 24.90
Twelve By Twelve Sparkle Sweater Tunic Forever21 $26.00
Chunky Knit Scarf Forever21 $12.80
Women's Merona Cable Knit Gloves - Tan Target $7.68
Merona Mittens - Green Target $5.48
Pointelle Crochet Beret Forever21 $5.80